How to Convert Expired Listing Leads (The Smart Agent’s Playbook

Most expired listing leads sit untouched because agents either don’t know how to approach them—or they quit after one call. That’s the leak.

But here’s how you plug it. Lead with empathy. Execute a disciplined multi-touch plan. Bring a new, convincing marketing strategy. Keep the beat and you’ll earn more appointments, more listings, and a pipeline that finally feels predictable.

Why expired listing leads are different (and better)

These aren’t cold prospects. They’ve already been through photos, showings, and price talks. And the issue with them was usually pricing, marketing, timing, or representation—not motivation. Your advantage is simple: arrive with empathy and a plan that clearly fixes what failed last time.

Step 1: Find expired listing leads daily

Work new expireds first thing in the morning. Pull them from your MLS and, if you like, supplement with third-party lists or dialers. Speed matters; by the weekend, the most motivated sellers will be talking to someone else.

Pro tip: Block a 30-minute daily “Expireds First” power session. Even 5 high-quality touches a day beats a once-a-week sprint.

Step 2: Qualify for highest win rate

• Neighborhood & price band: Focus where demand and comps are strongest.
• Presentation potential: Photos show promise (or can be fixed with light staging).
• Why they were moving: Time-sensitive moves (job, school, family) convert faster.

Qualifying protects your time and keeps your momentum focused on listings most likely to sign.

Step 3: Contact with empathy (not a hard pitch)

Lead with curiosity, not claims. They’ve already heard promises. Earn the conversation first.

“I noticed your home came off the market. Are you still interested in selling, or did your plans change?”

Listen. Reflect what you hear. Then bridge to solutions that directly address their pain (pricing clarity, better marketing, stronger showing plan).

How to convert expired listing leads with a simple multi-touch cadence

One touch rarely wins. Set a short, respectful cadence that keeps you top-of-mind without pressure:

• Day 1: Call. If no answer, leave a brief voicemail (name recognition + reason).
• Day 2: Mail an expired listing letter that empathizes and outlines a fresh plan.
• Day 5: Light text or email: “Would a quick pricing update help?”
• Week 2: Send a one-page market update with new comps + days on market trend.
• Week 3: Second letter or drop-by with a short leave-behind (mini plan checklist).

Each touch adds value. Each message reinforces that you solve the specific problem they experienced.

Show a fresh plan they can believe in

To convert expired listing leads, present a fresh, believable plan that directly fixes what failed the first time.

• Pricing clarity: Transparent comps, micro-market trends, and a “strategy price” with runway.
• Presentation: Staging checklist, pro photos, twilight exteriors, and a 60–90s video tour.
• Promotion: MLS + social ads, email to buyers’ agents, circle prospecting, and two well-timed open houses.
• Feedback loop: Post-showing follow-ups and weekly seller briefings with actions, not excuses.

When they see a plan that fixes yesterday’s gaps, sellers shift from skeptical to confident—and they sign.

Quick success snapshot

A Midwest agent mailed 10 expired letters a day for 3 weeks, followed her cadence, and booked three listing appointments. Two signed; one sold in 17 days. Small daily actions, done consistently, beat sporadic sprints every time. That rhythm is exactly how to convert expired listing leads consistently—without sounding pushy.

Authoritative resource

For more tactical ideas and scripts, this industry guide is a solid reference:

👉 How to Get Expired Listings: 9 Strategies & Conversion Tips (The Close)

Related pages you might like

Harness The Magic - Mail Letters To Expired Listings
Expired Listing Prospect - The Cat's Meow
Expired Listing Letter Campaigns
How to Get Expired Listings: 9 Strategies & Conversion Tips

Home > Expired Listings >> Expired Listing Leads